And now for an insight into the bureaucracy of the City of Philadelphia...
ARCHITECTURAL COMMITTEE, 24 JANUARY 2012 1
PHILADELPHIA HISTORICAL COMMISSIONADDRESS: 127 S 18TH STProject: Install awning and signage
Review Requested: Final Approval
Owner: ADR 18th and Sansom LLC
Applicant:
Nicole Marquis, Hip City VegHistory: 1870; storefront added, 1915
Individual Designation: None
District Designation: Rittenhouse Fitler Residential Historic District, Contributing, 2/8/1995
Staff Contact: Erin Cote,
erin.cote@phila.gov, 215-686-7660
OVERVIEW: This application proposes to install a wood awning above the non-historic storefront
at 127 S. 18th Street. The awning would be supported by an aluminum frame mounted into
existing bracket holes. The awning will consist of six-inch oak boards spaced three inches apart
over the aluminum frame. This application also proposes vinyl decal signage for the storefront
window.
STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Denial, pursuant to Standard 9.
DISCUSSION: Ms. Coté presented the application to the Architectural Committee. Business
owner Nicole Marquis represented the application.
Ms. Marquis stated that the Sign Committee of the Art Commission reviewed her proposal last
week and that the members of the Committee stated that they would approve the awning,
contingent on the Historical Commission’s approval. She stated that her new restaurant is
intended to be an example of sustainability and this would carry through to the reclaimed wood
awning. She stated that the awning would consist of oak that will look exquisite and would
complement the Rittenhouse Square area. She opined that the proposed awning would be an
improvement over the existing awning, which is a vinyl back-lit awning.
Mr. Evans asked the staff about the awning shown in the designation photo and the one that is
currently installed on the storefront. Ms. Cote explained that the awning in the designation photo
was grandfathered in with the designation and that the Commission has no record of review for
the existing awning. Mr. Evans informed the applicant that the existing awning is essentially
illegal.
Ms. Hawkins stated that historically awnings were made of fabric. She stated that she thought
that this was the first time the Committee had reviewed a proposal for a wood awning.
Ms. Marquis clarified that this awning may require new installation holes, but that she would use
existing holes where possible. She stated that she would patch the old holes with the dust from
the new holes. She stated that this would make the building look even better. She stated that
the awning will need to be supported every 30 inches as opposed to every 36 inches. She
supplied a photograph of a wood awning found in Center City. She stated that she proposed to
have a metal frame around the wood as shown in the photograph.
ORDER OF AGENDA SUBJECT TO CHANGE
AGENDA
595TH STATED MEETING OF THE
PHILADELPHIA HISTORICAL COMMISSION
FRIDAY, 9 MARCH 2012, 9:00 A.M.
1515 ARCH STREET, ROOM 18-029
SAM SHERMAN, JR., CHAIR
ADDRESS: 127 S 18TH ST
Project: Install awning and signage
Type of Review Requested: Final Approval
Owner: ADR 18th and Sansom LLC
Applicant:
Nicole Marquis, Hip City VegHistory: 1870
Individual Designation: None
District Designation: Rittenhouse Fitler Residential Historic District, Contributing, 2/8/1995
Staff Contact: Erin Cote,
erin.cote@phila.gov, 215-686-7660
Good luck tomorrow, Ms. Marquis!